Tasers in Italy: Use of Force, Health Risks, and Fundamental Rights
Analysis of the Use of Stun Guns by Law Enforcement Agencies
In the 2026 update to the report on Tasers, Strali analyzes the legal, health, and operational aspects related to the use of electric-shock weapons in Italy.
The Taser as an “intermediate” tool
This report is set against the backdrop of the growing use of Tasers, which were initially introduced on a trial basis and subsequently expanded—including at the local level—through various regulatory measures. At the same time, public debate often continues to portray this device as an intermediate technical solution, capable of reducing the use of firearms and ensuring greater safety during police operations.
Classifying the Taser as an “intermediate instrument” risks fostering a perception that it is less dangerous, which could lead to its more frequent use, with the risk of undermining the requirements of necessity and proportionality mandated by the justifications (Articles 52–53 of the Criminal Code) and of introducing a sort of “presumed proportionality” simply because a firearm was not used.
Health Risks and the Concept of “Less-Lethal Weapons”
StraLi believes, however, that it is necessary to critically examine this narrative. The Taser is classified as a “less-lethal” weapon, but this definition should not be confused with the absence of risks. The device works by delivering electrical shocks designed to affect the neuromuscular system of the person targeted and can have significant health consequences, particularly in cases of heart disease, agitation, substance use, mental distress, or other conditions of vulnerability.
The Concerns of International Organizations
In recent years, international bodies, independent authorities, and human rights organizations have drawn attention to the risks associated with the use of stun guns. The European Committee for the Prevention of Torture has emphasized the need for particular caution, especially with regard to vulnerable individuals, while the United Nations Committee Against Torture has in the past expressed serious concerns regarding the physical and mental effects of such devices. The National Ombudsman for the Rights of Persons Detained or Deprived of Liberty has also highlighted the need for clear limits, stringent safeguards, and full compliance with the obligations arising from Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
The use of stun guns on individuals suffering from agitated delirium or under the influence of alcohol or drugs requires extreme caution, since individuals in this state of confusion are very likely to fail to understand the warning that the weapon will be used against them and may become even more agitated.
The Risk of Normalization in Operational Use
In this context, the main concern is the risk that the Taser will become normalized as a routine means of restraint. A review of known cases in Italy reveals that the device is often used in situations involving outbursts, agitation, or vulnerability—and not necessarily in contexts where the use of a firearm would otherwise have been justified. In this sense, the Taser appears in practice not only as an alternative to a handgun but also as an alternative to physical restraint, with significant implications for the proportionality of the intervention.
Contributing Causes, Vulnerability, and Legal Liability
We also analyzed the issue of contributing factors in the use of Tasers, focusing on how preexisting medical conditions, altered states resulting from substance use, and specific individual vulnerabilities can contribute to the occurrence of injurious or fatal events. Criminal case law holds, in fact, that such factors do not automatically exclude a causal link with the officer’s conduct when the latter contributes in a concrete way to the occurrence of the event. An analysis of recent cases and the rulings of the Court of Cassation shows that, even in the context of Taser use, the risk often stems from the interaction between the electric shock and the condition of the person struck. Particular attention has also been paid to the use of the device against individuals in an agitated state, a situation in which the device’s deterrent effectiveness may be reduced and the risk of repeated use of electric shocks may increase.
In the context of Taser use, a contributing factor (such as acute cardiac arrest) does not necessarily act as an independent and exclusive cause of the event.
Reported deaths and the need for monitoring
Between August and October 2025, according to sources cited in the report, at least four deaths were recorded in incidents where a Taser was reportedly used. Although these are separate incidents and some are still under investigation, these incidents highlight the need for rigorous, public, and independent oversight capable of documenting not only the outcome of the interventions but also the condition of the person targeted, the number and duration of the shocks, the availability of operational alternatives, and the actual proportionality of the use of force.
Public Safety and the Protection of Fundamental Rights
The purpose of this report is to contribute to a critical examination of the relationship between public safety needs and the protection of fundamental individual rights. It argues that even when a tool is presented as “less lethal,” its use must remain subject to a careful assessment of the specific case and to the protection of human health and dignity.
Passion and Expertise
These values define our work, which is fueled by volunteers who dedicate their skills and knowledge to protecting rights and serving society. Your contribution can help us create a lasting impact.